Top SEO Companies New York City, NY

Many New York City businesses both small and large prefer hiring SEO services based locally in New York City, NY. As an SEO professional with over 15 years experience in SEO, I wanted to provide a list of the top SEO companies in New York City, New York. I reviewed the services of over 50 SEO companies in New York City. From there I have narrowed down to the below top 10 SEO companies. SEO companies in this list were vetted based on a defined methodology with criteria we felt businesses care most about including but not limited to, a track record of client performance, the expertise of staff, and customer satisfaction. We receive no compensation from agencies in this list. If an SEO company is listed here, it is by their merit alone.

Written By: Andrew Eagar
Updated: 10/3/2024

The Agency Alternative

Tired of jumping from agency to agency?

Hire a fractional SEO Resource for twice the value at a fraction of the cost.

The Fractional SEO differs from traditional agencies in 4 key areas:

Expertise: The Fractional SEO has 15 years of SEO experience strategizing and implementing SEO campaigns for brands both large and small.
Cost Effective: The Fractional SEO is a single SEO consultant with minimal overhead.
Flexible Engagements: The reality of any marketing is that priorities change, resources are reallocated and to be agile in today’s market, the last thing you need is a 12 month contract. The Fractional SEO engagements are month-to-month
Integrated Support: The Fractional SEO is an integrated and active member of your marketing team. More collaboration, better communication with SEO being fully integrated in all other marketing initiatives.

Best SEO Companies in New York City, NY

Big Drop Inc

Company Overview: Big Drop Inc provides a wide range of SEO services, from keyword research to technical optimization. Their focus on content marketing and website analytics helps businesses improve their search rankings and grow their organic traffic effectively.

Customer Quote:

“If you reading this post and thinking about using Big Drop enjoy them they exceeded my expectations.”

Why We Chose Them:

Big Drop Inc made our list of top SEO agencies in New York City, boasting the largest marketing team with 76 employees, including a dedicated SEO department. Their Google reviews showcase impressive results. One business noted significant growth in their school’s online traffic and SEO, doubling their Google position. Another praised their marketing strategies, helping them attract new clients. From SEO to web development, Big Drop’s expertise consistently delivers impactful results for a wide range of businesses.

HOZIO

Company Overview: Hozio specializes in SEO strategies that boost visibility and search rankings. With services like keyword research, technical SEO, and content creation, they help businesses grow their online presence and attract more organic traffic.

Customer Quote:

“I have been with Hozio for the past 3 years and they did a beautiful job with my website and SEO.”

Why We Chose Them:

HOZIO was selected by our team for our NY City SEO agency list due to their strong agency structure and glowing reviews. In a case study with Apex Air Duct Cleaning, HOZIO helped boost visibility and leads through localized SEO, Google Business Profile optimization, and a targeted Google Ads campaign. The results? Over 13,000 phone calls in two years, ranking #1 on Google Maps within 11 miles, and 60% of 4,800 keywords in the top 5. A truly impressive performance.

Sure Oak

Company Overview: Sure Oak offers customized SEO strategies to drive organic traffic and enhance visibility. With services like link building, content marketing, and keyword optimization, they help businesses improve search rankings and achieve their digital growth goals.

Customer Quote:

“Andrea and Henrique are wonderful to work with. They both treat our company like it’s their own.”

Why We Chose Them:

Sure Oak earned a spot on our agency list for their 29 glowing Google reviews, where the keyword “SEO results” consistently shines through. One NY City client, a PI attorney, praised their ability to get businesses to the top of Google Maps and deliver skilled SEO and PPC strategies. Another review from Novarad highlighted Sure Oak’s deep understanding of complex industries like medical imaging, consistently boosting their SEO.

JH SEO

Company Overview: Jh SEO Agency provides comprehensive SEO services, from keyword research to content development. Their expertise in web design and social media management helps clients improve visibility, attract more traffic, and build a stronger online presence.

Customer Quote:

“He has been handling our website edits and SEO for a few years now and has done top notch work.”

Why We Chose Them:

We selected JH SEO for our NY City agency list because of their specialized expertise and outstanding client reviews. Customers consistently praise Jimmy Huh for delivering beyond expectations with SEO and web marketing services. One client specifically highlighted Jimmy’s expertise as a top SEO consultant in New York, leading to perfect SEO results. For businesses seeking reliable and effective SEO solutions, JH SEO stands out as a trusted partner.

Griffon Webstudios Inc

Company Overview: Griffon Web Studios provides full-scale SEO services along with web design and digital marketing. Their solutions, including local SEO and link building, focus on improving visibility and driving targeted traffic to help businesses grow online.

Customer Quote:

“They were courteous, fast and professional, and are great at what they do.”

Why We Chose Them:

To wrap up our NY City SEO list, we selected Griffon Webstudios because of their impressive case studies. Ocean Waves Sunglasses: Migrated from BigCommerce to Shopify, Griffon integrated a “3D Try-On” feature. This led to a 56% increase in organic traffic and better keyword rankings. Loonyx Shop Mart: Using BigCommerce, Griffon revamped Loonyx’s site with intuitive navigation and responsive design. The result? A seamless online experience that’s ready to captivate more customers.

SearchBerg

Company Overview: Searchberg offers a full suite of digital marketing services, including SEO, content creation, and link building. Their focus on boosting online visibility and driving organic traffic helps businesses achieve higher search rankings and expand their digital footprint.

Customer Quote:

“Eric has been great as well. SearchBerg is awesome for white label website solutions.”

Why We Chose Them:

SearchBerg may be the highest-rated SEO agency we’ve seen in NY City, with 265 Google reviews, many of which are focused on their SEO services. One client highlighted Sam’s continuous support, which led to top search rankings, while another applauded the website redesign process, where every step was approved and tailored to the client’s needs. SearchBerg’s expert team, attention to detail, and results-driven approach make them a clear choice for businesses looking to grow online.

e9digital

Company Overview: E9 Digital offers expert SEO solutions designed to enhance visibility and drive traffic. They specialize in keyword research, content marketing, and link building, helping businesses grow their digital presence and see measurable results through tailored strategies.

Customer Quote:

“I highly recommend e9digital for anyone seeking to work with a highly dependable team.”

Why We Chose Them:

With 93 perfect reviews, e9digital stands as one of the top SEO agencies on our New York City list. The keywords that we found in their reviews are professionalism, creativity, and commitment to delivering on time and within budget. We read about a client, a business consultant, who praised e9digital for creating a unique, high-quality website that exceeded expectations. Another client highlighted their seamless team approach, which made the process easy, and ultimately led to a rebrand that knocked it out of the park.

5Boro Digital Marketing

Company Overview: 5Boro Digital delivers SEO and digital marketing services aimed at improving website performance and driving organic traffic. Their data-driven approach includes local SEO, content marketing, and analytics, ensuring businesses see long-term growth in their online visibility.

Customer Quote:

“The team is knowledgeable and truly cares about our success. Highly recommend.”

Why We Chose Them:

5Boro Digital Marketing is a standout in our NY City SEO Agency list, boasting an impressive collection of 30 case studies focused on SEO results. One of our favorite examples features a Lawyer Chain that came to them in 2016. Initially ranking for just six keywords, 5Boro’s SEO strategy, which included extensive keyword research and on/off-page optimization, boosted their ranking to 254 keywords on the first page within 18 months—a staggering 4,133% increase. Organic sessions grew by 36.6%, leading to impressive business growth.

GVATE

Company Overview: Gvate excels in technical SEO and digital marketing. By offering services such as keyword research, on-page optimization, and web design, they help businesses enhance search rankings and drive more organic traffic, leading to improved online visibility.

Customer Quote:

“These guys are transparent, professional and care about your business.”

Why We Chose Them:

We chose GVATE for our NY City list because one word that resonated a lot in their client testimonials is “”results.”” After analyzing their work, we found examples of incredible growth. Clients have seen their annual revenue goals met in just a few months, thanks to GVATE’s SEO strategies. From eCommerce growth to improving lead quality, their team consistently delivers outstanding outcomes, making them a top contender for businesses seeking serious digital growth in New York.

SEO Image

Company Overview: SEO Image helps businesses enhance their digital presence through expert SEO strategies. Their services, from keyword research to content creation, focus on driving organic traffic and improving search rankings, providing comprehensive digital solutions to grow online visibility.

Customer Quote:

“Alan is extremely knowledgeable and on top of the SEO Trends to make sure you keep your rankings.”

Why We Chose Them:

We were highly impressed with SEO Image’s case studies, securing them a spot on our NY City SEO Agency list. For Stackoverdrive, a DevOps startup, SEO Image took them from zero traffic to thousands of visitors, helping them grow enough to make the Inc. 5000 list. Their work with Related Rentals, a major real estate developer, produced Top 5 rankings for competitive terms like “Apartment Rentals,” boosting their visibility and online traffic significantly.

Our Methodology For Ranking New York City SEO Companies

I evaluated 50 New York City SEO agencies factoring in over 50 relevant points of information for each. Below is an outline of the categories I evaluated.

Client Performance: For each agency in this list I review case studies and the specific reviews from customers to gauge client performance. I look for clear factors of successful performance such as keyword ranking, traffic increases, and lead growth.
Employee Experience: I review the LinkedIn profiles of every SEO employee at each of the SEO New York City SEO agencies. I look for total years of SEO specific experience and the overall depth of that experience. I identify if their experience is more strategic, customer service, or implementation focused.
Customer Satisfaction: I review customer reviews on Google and other 3rd party websites. I evaluate the quality of the review and what customers enjoyed about their experience. I look for ratings on customer service and performance. I also looked for indications of the length of client engagements which all denote high levels of customer satisfaction.
Location: I made sure that each business listed on this page is located in or near New York City, NY.

About the Author

Andrew Eagar

Andrew Eagar is an SEO expert with over 15 years of SEO experience. He has been the Director of SEO at 4 different agencies. He has built SEO departments from the ground up, has lead SEO teams of over 25 people, and has contributed SEO thought leadership to websites like Moz, Clutch, and many others.

Andrew’s experience leading SEO agencies at 4 different companies makes him uniquely qualified to assess the value and quality of each. He can look beyond agency marketing material and assess the substance of their value and the quality of their work.

Andrew is the Founder and CEO of The Fractional SEO, an agency alternative. The Fractional SEO works to bridge the gap between agency and in-house.

contact@thefractionalseo.com

(804) 767-2545