Top SEO Companies Lancaster, PA

Many Lancaster businesses both small and large prefer hiring SEO services based locally in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. As an SEO professional with over 15 years experience in SEO, I wanted to provide a list of the top SEO companies in Lancaster, PA. I reviewed the services of over 36 SEO companies in Lancaster. From there I have narrowed down to the below top 12 SEO companies. SEO companies in this list were vetted based on a defined methodology with criteria we felt businesses care most about including but not limited to, a track record of client performance, the expertise of staff, and customer satisfaction. We receive no compensation from agencies in this list. If an SEO company is listed here, it is by their merit alone.

Written By: Andrew Eagar
Updated: 10/15/2024

The Agency Alternative

Tired of jumping from agency to agency?

Hire a fractional SEO Resource for twice the value at a fraction of the cost.

The Fractional SEO differs from traditional agencies in 4 key areas:

Expertise: The Fractional SEO has 15 years of SEO experience strategizing and implementing SEO campaigns for brands both large and small.
Cost Effective: The Fractional SEO is a single SEO consultant with minimal overhead.
Flexible Engagements: The reality of any marketing is that priorities change, resources are reallocated and to be agile in today’s market, the last thing you need is a 12 month contract. The Fractional SEO engagements are month-to-month
Integrated Support: The Fractional SEO is an integrated and active member of your marketing team. More collaboration, better communication with SEO being fully integrated in all other marketing initiatives.

Best SEO Companies in Lancaster, PA

Tower Marketing

Company Overview: Tower Marketing offers SEO services such as keyword research, on-page optimization, and local SEO. They also provide web design, social media marketing, PPC, email marketing, and branding. Their SEO focuses on improving search rankings and driving targeted traffic for business growth.

Customer Quote:

“As a one-woman marketing team, Tower Marketing is my right-hand of my marketing department.”

Why We Chose Them:

Tower Marketing caught our attention with their compelling case studies, leading us to include them in our list. One particular case study left a lasting impression, highlighting their achievement of generating 16,000 views on Google Maps within 6 months, alongside over 336,000 impressions and 46,400 clicks to the website by targeting local cities over 16 months. These impressive outcomes were attributed to their strategic implementation of Google My Business optimization and a local SEO approach.

5K Media

Company Overview: 5K Media offers SEO services like keyword optimization, local SEO, and content strategy. They also provide web design, AI integration, video production, and paid traffic management, focusing on driving growth, improving search visibility, and enhancing customer engagement through customized marketing strategies.

Customer Quote:

“Our online presence has significantly improved, with notable increases in website traffic.”

Why We Chose Them:

Marble Marketing made our list5K Media garnered a place on our compilation of top SEO companies in Lancaster, PA, primarily due to its stellar reputation reflected in 36 glowing Google reviews. What stood out in these customer feedbacks was the personal touch: customers mentioned team members by name and referred to 5K Media as a ‘partner’, reflecting the level of trust and customer satisfaction. One notable client testimonial highlights a 500% increase in ecommerce sales within just one year of collaboration with 5K Media.

NetConnect Digital Agency

Company Overview: NetConnect Digital is an SEO agency based in Lancaster, PA. They offer services such as SEO, web design, social media marketing, and PPC. The company focuses on providing comprehensive SEO solutions, including keyword research, on-page optimization, link building, and content marketing to help businesses improve their online presence and drive organic traffic.

Customer Quote:

“They manage my Website SEO. And Im 100% happy with their service.”

Why We Chose Them:

NetConnect is another standout SEO agency based in Lancaster, PA, where we found great reviews from satisfied clients. The review that caught our attention was a client mentioning PPC management, calling them the best in the USA, with professional service at affordable pricing. Many also highlighted their SEO packages, which are both budget-friendly and effective, leading to noticeable results.

WTM Digital

Company Overview: WTM Digital is an SEO agency located in Lancaster, PA. They offer services such as web design, digital marketing, and social media management. Their SEO offering includes on-page optimization, off-page optimization, and keyword research to improve website visibility and drive organic traffic.

Customer Quote:

“Only been working with Web Talent for 6 months, our web traffic & online sales grow exponentially.”

Why We Chose Them:

Due to exceptional feedback from 15 impressive Google reviews, we added WTM Digital to our list of best SEO agencies in Lancaster, PA. As we reviewed each testimonial, we were struck by the consistent praise for WTM Digital’s marketing services, including SEO, in enhancing web traffic, securing top Google rankings, and driving significant growth in sales and leads. Notably, one client highlighted a remarkable 75% increase in website traffic and achieving number one rankings for multiple keywords.

YDOP

Company Overview: YDOP is an SEO agency located in Lancaster, PA. They offer SEO services with a focus on local and organic search, technical SEO, and content strategy. In addition to SEO, they also provide PPC advertising, web design, and social media marketing services.

Customer Quote:

“This company is generous with their resources and is committed to broad community support.”

Why We Chose Them:

We’ve selected YDOP as one of the top SEO companies in Lancaster, PA, due to their impressive performance highlighted in 61 Google reviews. What truly stood out in these reviews was the consistent praise from customers for YDOP’s ability to deliver tangible SEO results, including significant growth in web traffic and leads. Clients also highlighted their proficiency in crafting and executing effective marketing strategies tailored to their specific needs.

Infantree

Company Overview: Infantree is an SEO agency based in Lancaster, PA. They offer digital marketing services, web design, and branding. Their SEO services include keyword research, on-page optimization, link building, and content strategy to improve website visibility and drive organic traffic.

Customer Quote:

“Their insightful process it may take a little longer, delivers results for long term success.”

Why We Chose Them:

Infantree was added to our list through a combination of compelling case studies and positive customer reviews. While I read all case studies, one in particular stood out: it showcased a 20% increase in traffic, a 9% decrease in bounce rate, achieved 36% conversion rate for a specific tool, and generated 1,430 searches for another tool, all attributed to an effective content strategy. Additionally, another noteworthy case study highlighted a 12% boost in sales and successfully recaptured 26% of abandoned carts through an effective ecommerce strategy.

Improve & Grow, LLC

Company Overview: Improve & Grow provides SEO services focused on local SEO, keyword optimization, and content strategies. They also offer web design, digital marketing, and lead generation services. Their SEO approach centers on improving search rankings, driving traffic, and delivering measurable growth for businesses.

Customer Quote:

“A huge thank you to Carl for working with us & helping us to understand our market and business!”

Why We Chose Them:

We added Improve & Grow, LLC to our lineup after reviewing their compelling case studies. Each case study revealed impressive results, such as a 511% increase in annual website traffic, a 248% rise in annual website transactions, and a 215% increase in annual website revenue attributable to their effective technical SEO strategy. These remarkable outcomes commend the commitment level and SEO expertise of the Improve & Grow,LLC team.

Scheffey Marketing & Communications

Company Overview: Scheffey is an SEO agency based in Lancaster, PA, offering a range of digital marketing services such as web design, content marketing, and social media management. They specialize in SEO strategy, keyword research, on-page optimization, and link building to help businesses improve their online visibility and drive organic traffic to their websites.

Customer Quote:

“Their professionalism, upfront communication, and positive outlook makes them easy to recommend.”

Why We Chose Them:

Scheffey Marketing & Communications earned a spot among our top-rated SEO firms in Lancaster, PA, based on both client testimonials on their website and 7 Google reviews. Our detailed analysis of both customer feedbacks and Google reviews reveals that customers frequently mention team members by name and have maintained long-term working partnerships with Scheffey Marketing & Communications. This reflects the deep level of trust and customer satisfaction their clients have experienced.

Oostas

Company Overview: Oostas is an SEO agency based in Lancaster, PA, offering services such as web design, content marketing, and social media management. Their SEO services include keyword research, on-page optimization, and link building to help businesses improve their online visibility and drive organic traffic to their websites.

Customer Quote:

“I would recommend Oostas to anyone looking to build their online presence!”

Why We Chose Them:

We decided to feature Oostas in our list of top SEO companies in Lancaster, PA, largely due to their 80 positive customer reviews with an average rating of 5.0. Our evaluation of these reviews reveal that many customers have benefited from a range of services, including SEO, provided by Oostas. Clients particularly lauded Oostas for their commitment and efforts in supporting small businesses, alongside their appreciation for responsiveness and high-quality work.

MIND Development & Design

Company Overview: MIND Development & Design provides SEO services focused on on-page optimization, keyword strategies, and local SEO. They also offer web design, development, and content management services, with an emphasis on improving search visibility and enhancing website performance to drive growth.

Customer Quote:

“MIND is great to work with. I could not ask for a better partner. Totally on top of the game.”

Why We Chose Them:

MIND Development & Design joined our curated list primarily due to their comprehensive case studies. After careful analysis, one particular case study stood out, showcasing a significant 56.96% increase in organic traffic, a 43.38% rise in new users, and a 22.97% improvement in goal completion. These achievements are credited to their SEO efforts, which include content creation and PPC advertising. This case study demonstrates the expertise and capability of MIND Development & Design’s team in delivering impressive SEO results for their clients.

Local Search and Marketing Experts

Company Overview: Local Search and Marketing is a leading SEO agency based in Lancaster, PA. They offer a range of services including SEO, social media marketing, and web design. Their SEO offering includes keyword research, on-page optimization, link building, and content creation to help businesses improve their online visibility and drive more organic traffic.

Customer Quote:

“We are busy and just could not make the time for this. He makes it easy for us.”

Why We Chose Them:

Local Search and Marketing Experts, run by Eric Godgrey, is like having a marketing director at a third of the cost, based on their stellar reviews from their Lancaster, PA location. We concluded that they can handle social media and reputation management effortlessly, making it easy for busy businesses to stay on top of their online presence. One reviewer emphasized how adding LSAME feels like gaining a full marketing director at a fraction of the price, while another simply called them the “go-to” team for digital marketing.

Kern Web Design

Company Overview: Kern Web Design offers SEO services, including technical and on-site SEO, to enhance search rankings and website performance. They also provide custom web design, website maintenance, speed optimization, and on-demand support, focusing on strategic growth through user-friendly, high-performance websites.

Customer Quote:

“He set me up for success in knowing how to handle my new site. Would definitly recommend!”

Why We Chose Them:

Kern Web Design earned a spot among our selection of the best SEO agencies in Lancaster, PA, based on stellar client testimonials featured on their website and an outstanding average of 5.0 from 9 Google reviews. What stood out to me in these reviews was how customers not only recall staff members by name but also highlighted the variety of services provided by Kern Web Design. This demonstrates the high level of customer satisfaction and the quality work that Kern Web Design delivers.

Our Methodology For Ranking Lancaster SEO Companies

I evaluated 36 Lancaster SEO agencies factoring in over 50 relevant points of information for each. Below is an outline of the categories I evaluated.

Client Performance: For each agency in this list I review case studies and the specific reviews from customers to gauge client performance. I look for clear factors of successful performance such as keyword ranking, traffic increases, and lead growth.
Employee Experience: I review the LinkedIn profiles of every SEO employee at each of the SEO Lancaster SEO agencies. I look for total years of SEO specific experience and the overall depth of that experience. I identify if their experience is more strategic, customer service, or implementation focused.
Customer Satisfaction: I review customer reviews on Google and other 3rd party websites. I evaluate the quality of the review and what customers enjoyed about their experience. I look for ratings on customer service and performance. I also looked for indications of the length of client engagements which all denote high levels of customer satisfaction.
Location: I made sure that each business listed on this page is located in or near Lancaster, PA.

About the Author

Andrew Eagar

Andrew Eagar is an SEO expert with over 15 years of SEO experience. He has been the Director of SEO at 4 different agencies. He has built SEO departments from the ground up, has lead SEO teams of over 25 people, and has contributed SEO thought leadership to websites like Moz, Clutch, and many others.

Andrew’s experience leading SEO agencies at 4 different companies makes him uniquely qualified to assess the value and quality of each. He can look beyond agency marketing material and assess the substance of their value and the quality of their work.

Andrew is the Founder and CEO of The Fractional SEO, an agency alternative. The Fractional SEO works to bridge the gap between agency and in-house.

contact@thefractionalseo.com

(804) 767-2545