Top SEO Companies Pittsburgh, PA

Many Pittsburgh businesses both small and large prefer hiring SEO services based locally in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. As an SEO professional with over 15 years experience in SEO, I wanted to provide a list of the top SEO companies in Pittsburgh, PA. I reviewed the services of over 36 SEO companies in Pittsburgh. From there I have narrowed down to the below top 11 SEO companies. SEO companies in this list were vetted based on a defined methodology with criteria we felt businesses care most about including but not limited to, a track record of client performance, the expertise of staff, and customer satisfaction. We receive no compensation from agencies in this list. If an SEO company is listed here, it is by their merit alone.

Written By: Andrew Eagar
Updated: 10/15/2024

The Agency Alternative

Tired of jumping from agency to agency?

Hire a fractional SEO Resource for twice the value at a fraction of the cost.

The Fractional SEO differs from traditional agencies in 4 key areas:

Expertise: The Fractional SEO has 15 years of SEO experience strategizing and implementing SEO campaigns for brands both large and small.
Cost Effective: The Fractional SEO is a single SEO consultant with minimal overhead.
Flexible Engagements: The reality of any marketing is that priorities change, resources are reallocated and to be agile in today’s market, the last thing you need is a 12 month contract. The Fractional SEO engagements are month-to-month
Integrated Support: The Fractional SEO is an integrated and active member of your marketing team. More collaboration, better communication with SEO being fully integrated in all other marketing initiatives.

Best SEO Companies in Pittsburgh, PA

Direct Online Marketing

Company Overview: Direct Online Marketing, based in Pittsburgh, PA, offers comprehensive SEO services such as on-page and off-page optimization, local SEO, and structured data implementation. They also specialize in web design, PPC, social media advertising, and conversion rate optimization, focusing on increasing traffic and boosting conversions.

Customer Quote:

“We recommend them for any one that wants to achieve great marketing results.”

Why We Chose Them:

Direct Online Marketing was included on our list due to their detailed case studies. We were astounded by the impressive SEO results showcased, such as a 2,800% increase in lead generation, a 44% year-over-year growth in traffic, and a 367% boost in overall traffic, achieved through an SEO strategy centered on full-scale blogging and outreach efforts. Additionally, they increased page one rankings by 109% in six months. These results demonstrate the SEO prowess of the Direct Online Marketing team.

Sixth City Marketing

Company Overview: Sixth City Marketing is a Pittsburgh-based SEO agency offering services such as web design, content marketing, and social media management. Their SEO services include keyword optimization, link building, and local SEO to help businesses improve their online visibility and drive organic traffic to their websites.

Customer Quote:

“We have significantly improved our SEO and website traffic by working with them.”

Why We Chose Them:

We included Sixth City Marketing in our list after a detailed review of their compelling case studies. One particular case study showcased impressive results, revealing a 540% increase in search engine traffic and a notable 314% rise in monthly leads. These outcomes were the result of their SEO efforts, including extensive keyword research and competitor analysis. Such case studies highlight the SEO expertise and effectiveness of the Sixth City Marketing team.

PIC

Company Overview: PIC is an SEO agency based in Pittsburgh, PA. They offer website design, SEO, and digital marketing services. Their SEO offering includes keyword research, on-page optimization, link building, and content creation. They aim to improve online visibility and drive organic traffic to their clients’ websites.

Customer Quote:

“Very knowledgeable and professional – I would highly recommend PIC to any small business!”

Why We Chose Them:

We added PIC to our list after delving into their website’s case studies. We read several compelling examples, and one particular case study caught our attention, showcasing a 19% increase in organic traffic and a 66% boost in website leads within 6 months through collaborative efforts in SEO and web design. This success story also highlights significant improvements in product pages and strategic CTA Placement, which led to a 279% increase in total website leads.

Sparq Designs

Company Overview: Sparq Designs is a Pittsburgh-based SEO agency offering services such as web design, social media management, and digital marketing. Their SEO services include keyword research, on-page optimization, link building, and local SEO. They focus on driving organic traffic and improving search engine rankings for businesses in Pittsburgh, PA.

Customer Quote:

“Transfer Company’s website to increase SEO and have the website be responsive to mobile devices.”

Why We Chose Them:

Sparq Designs was featured on our list based on a combination of their compelling case studies and impressive Google reviews. One standout case study revealed a remarkable 310% increase in organic website traffic following the implementation of various SEO strategies, including email marketing. Clients in the Google reviews also praised the Sparq Designs team for their SEO expertise and commitment to delivering impactful results.

Vendilli Digital Group

Company Overview: Vendilli is a Pittsburgh-based SEO agency offering services such as web design, digital marketing, and branding. Their SEO services include keyword research, on-page optimization, link building, and local SEO. They are dedicated to improving online visibility and driving organic traffic to businesses in Pittsburgh, PA.

Customer Quote:

“I highly recommend Vendilli to get you to the next level with your site and marketing needs.”

Why We Chose Them:

Vendilli Digital Group has been included in our list due to their insightful case studies featured on their website. One specific case study left a lasting impression on us with remarkable results, such as a 51% increase in website users year over year, a 229% rise in website conversions, and 143% improvement in the conversion rate of interested traffic, all attributed to their SEO and PPC initiatives. These results commend the marketing prowess, especially in SEO, of the Vendilli Digital Group team.

Responsival

Company Overview: Responsival offers SEO services, including on-page and off-page SEO, technical SEO, and content optimization. They also specialize in Webflow development, UX design, and growth marketing. Their SEO strategies aim to enhance search visibility, optimize user experience, and drive conversions through tailored solutions.

Customer Quote:

“They were attentive and responsive and helped navigate us through the process.”

Why We Chose Them:

Responsival earned a spot on our list of top SEO companies in Pittsburgh, PA, not solely due to their impressive case studies, but also for their outstanding 4.9 rating based on 59 customer reviews. I reviewed each client feedback and was impressed by the long-standing partnerships many clients have maintained with Responsival, highlighting the high degree of customization in their services that reflects customer satisfaction.

Blue Archer

Company Overview: Blue Archer offers SEO services, including local SEO, on-page optimization, and content strategy. They also provide web design, custom software development, and digital marketing solutions, focusing on improving search rankings, user engagement, and delivering measurable results for businesses.

Customer Quote:

“We were so pleased with the process and the final product, that we are working with them again!”

Why We Chose Them:

Blue Archer earned a place on our list of best SEO agencies in Pittsburgh, PA, primarily due to their 127 impressive Google reviews with an average rating of 4.9. What stood out to us in these reviews was how many customers praised specific team members by name and expressed satisfaction with the results achieved through their collaboration with Blue Archer. Moreover, reviewers also lauded the communication, professionalism and work process of Blue Archer team.

Redtree Web Design

Company Overview: RedTree offers SEO services such as keyword optimization, content strategy, and technical SEO. They also provide web design, UX design, web development, and data analysis, focusing on improving search rankings and delivering user-centered, high-performance websites to drive conversions.

Customer Quote:

“I couldn’t have asked for a better, her expertise is unmatched. I highly recommend RedTree team!”

Why We Chose Them:

Redtree Web Design secured a prestigious spot on our list of best SEO firms in Pittsburgh, PA, based on their impressive case studies and 37 Google reviews averaging a 5.0 rating. Upon reviewing all feedback, I noticed customers often recall team members by name and refer to Redtree Web Design as their ‘partner’. These sentiments in customer feedback demonstrate the high level of trust and customer satisfaction achieved by Redtree Web Design.

Paper Box SEO

Company Overview: Paper Box SEO is an SEO agency based in Pittsburgh, PA. They offer services such as website audits, keyword research, on-page optimization, link building, and content creation. Their focus is on helping businesses improve their online visibility and increase their organic search traffic through effective SEO strategies.

Customer Quote:

“Their customized SEO plan aligns perfectly with our business goals and objectives.”

Why We Chose Them:

Paper Box SEO was added to our list based on detailed case studies showcased on their website. One particular case study stood out to us, highlighting a 467% year-over-year growth in organic sales and a 300% increase in organic visibility in under a year. This success was attributed to an effective SEO strategy encompassing on-page optimization and content writing. Additionally, they achieved top 3 rankings for their 30 target keywords and secured the #1 position for their highest volume keywords within just 16 months.

Digital Dynamo LLC

Company Overview: Digital Dynamo is an SEO Agency based in Pittsburgh, PA, offering services such as web design, social media management, and pay-per-click advertising. Their SEO offering includes keyword research, on-page optimization, and link building to improve website visibility and rankings. They also provide comprehensive SEO audits and analytics tracking for businesses.

Customer Quote:

“If you don’t know where to start with SEO, contact Marcie- I highly recommend her!”

Why We Chose Them:

Digital Dynamo LLC earned its place on our list through detailed case studies that left us thoroughly impressed. Their exceptional results include a staggering 1900% increase in keyword rankings, a 560% boost in organic traffic, and achieving top 10 positions for over 60 targeted keywords, marking a 600% increase. Their comprehensive SEO strategy covered all facets, from on-page and off-page optimizations to technical and local enhancements. Additionally, they captured a combined search volume of over 211,000 searches per month and secured top rankings in the local map pack.

Pittsburgh SEO Magician

Company Overview: Pittsburgh SEO Magician provides SEO services such as local SEO, business citation listings, and keyword optimization. They also offer website design, PPC management, social media marketing, and branding. Their SEO approach focuses on boosting search visibility, generating leads, and driving website traffic.

Customer Quote:

“Pittsburgh SEO Magician produces results. I would highly recommend Pittsburgh SEO Magician.”

Why We Chose Them:

Pittsburgh SEO Magician secured a position on our list of best SEO agencies in Pittsburgh, PA, on the strength of 25 Google reviews. We analyzed all customer feedback and noticed that one client highlighted achieving page 1 rankings for the first time, along with growth in online leads and phone calls, attributing these successes to Pittsburgh SEO Magician. Another client reported consistent success in generating targeted online leads weekly and receiving over 30 calls per month.

Our Methodology For Ranking Pittsburgh SEO Companies

I evaluated 36 Pittsburgh SEO agencies factoring in over 50 relevant points of information for each. Below is an outline of the categories I evaluated.

Client Performance: For each agency in this list I review case studies and the specific reviews from customers to gauge client performance. I look for clear factors of successful performance such as keyword ranking, traffic increases, and lead growth.
Employee Experience: I review the LinkedIn profiles of every SEO employee at each of the SEO Pittsburgh SEO agencies. I look for total years of SEO specific experience and the overall depth of that experience. I identify if their experience is more strategic, customer service, or implementation focused.
Customer Satisfaction: I review customer reviews on Google and other 3rd party websites. I evaluate the quality of the review and what customers enjoyed about their experience. I look for ratings on customer service and performance. I also looked for indications of the length of client engagements which all denote high levels of customer satisfaction.
Location: I made sure that each business listed on this page is located in or near Pittsburgh, PA.

About the Author

Andrew Eagar

Andrew Eagar is an SEO expert with over 15 years of SEO experience. He has been the Director of SEO at 4 different agencies. He has built SEO departments from the ground up, has lead SEO teams of over 25 people, and has contributed SEO thought leadership to websites like Moz, Clutch, and many others.

Andrew’s experience leading SEO agencies at 4 different companies makes him uniquely qualified to assess the value and quality of each. He can look beyond agency marketing material and assess the substance of their value and the quality of their work.

Andrew is the Founder and CEO of The Fractional SEO, an agency alternative. The Fractional SEO works to bridge the gap between agency and in-house.

contact@thefractionalseo.com

(804) 767-2545